Dinosaurs Extinction Essay, Research Paper

The first question that must be posed when trying to crack the mystery of the

mass extinction is to ask, throughout history were there any other occurences of

this magnitude? The answer is a resounding yes. Altogether over time there has

been about eight mass extinctions to large land dwelling vertebrates. The most

recent was about ten thousand years ago, killing most of the giant mammals like

mammoths, mastodons, super-large camels, saber-toothed tigers, and others (Bakker

428). The second question, is whether or not these mass extinctions follow a

pattern? Once again the answer is yes. Every time a mass extinction occurs on

the land ecosystem, the oceanic system is hurt. When the dinosaurs died, many

sea animals also died out (Bakker 428-430). The final question to be asked, is

when these mass extinctions occur, are both land and water animals affected, and

if so, are they affected at the same point in time? All saltwater animals

suffered, however, freshwater creatures were left unaffected. Plants on land did

suffer, but not nearly as much as the dinosaurs and other creatures that

depended on them as a food source.(Bakker 431). Since the time that the first

dinosaur was discovered, paleontologists have been pondering the demise of the

dinosaurs. Over a hundred theories have been produced to explain this mass

extinction (Psihoyos 255). The dinosaurs may have died because, "the

weather got too hot," ; "the weather got too cold," ; "the

weather got too dry," ; "the weather got too wet," ; "the

weather became too hot in the summer and too cold in the winter," ;

"the land became too hilly," ; "new kinds of plants evolved which

poisoned all the dinosaurs," ; "new kinds of insects evolved which

spread deadly diseases," ; "new kinds of mammals evolved which

competed for food," ; "new kinds of animals evolved which ate all of

the dinosaurs’ eggs," ; "a giant meteor hit the earth," ; "a

supernova exploded near the earth," ; "cosmic rays bombarded the

earth," ; or "massive volcanoes erupted all over the earth at once (Bakker

425)." Scientists’ beliefs seem to fall into two basic common positions,

the Catastrophists, and the Gradualists (Psihoyos 255). The Catastrophists

believe that a huge catastrophic event took place, killing all of the dinosaurs.

The most popular theory of the Catastrophists is the asteroid theory. An

asteroid called Chicxulub hit the earth creating a 150 mile wide crater near the

Yucatan Peninsula in Mexico. The date this asteroid hit the earth was sometime

about 65.7 million years ago, just about the time the dinosaurs died (Psihoyos

255). When this two-mile-wide asteroid hit the earth, it probably shattered and

sent tons and tons of asteroid-earth dust into the stratosphere. The lack of

light caused by the dust blocking out the sun would have caused many plants to

die out, leaving plant eating dinosaurs to die, and with no herbivores to hunt,

the carnivorous dinosaurs would die out, the domino effect (Krishtalka 19-20).

This event also would have frozen the earth, another reason why it would kill

all of the dinosaurs. No one can prove this theory, but it is one of the most

recent theories among scientists these days, as to what killed off all of the

dinosaurs. The dinosaurs were around for roughly 140 million years. They were

the ruling beasts of the earth for this whole period. Then, 65 million years ago

the dinosaurs just all died. None flying through the air, none swimming in the

water, none walking on land. They were all just gone. "The death of the

dinosaurs was the biggest mass extinction in the history of the earth (Bates

8-10)." The first clue that led scientists to the asteroid theory was the

finding of a thin layer of clay in the ground. In 1978 Walter Alvarez, a

Professor of geology from Berkeley, California, was driving up out of a deep

limestone gorge behind Gubbio, Italy, when he noticed something strange.

Limestone was formed when little prehistoric sea animals called forams died and

fell to the bottom of the ocean to form rock. When he was driving along he side

of this gorge he noticed that right at one point, all of the forams were gone.

This also happened to be a point in the ground right at 65 million years, right

about the time the dinosaurs died. Another strange thing Alvarez noticed was

that right in between the forams and the above rock was a thin layer of clay. He

felt that the clay might be important so he chipped a piece off, and hid it

away. Upon his arrival back in California he showed the clay to his father, Luis

Alvarez. Together they decided to find out what this clay was doing in the

middle of the rock. To see how long the clay took to form, the measured the

density of iridium, a metal in cosmic dust that the earth collects as it

revolves around the sun. To their amazement, though, the clay contained massive

amounts of iridium. Now they didn’t care how long the clay took to form, but why

it contained so much iridium. After a while, they came up with a working theory.

Perhaps a comet or asteroid crashed into the earth. Both of these contain

extremely high amounts of iridium, so it was a perfectly working explanation.

Upon impact this heavenly body would smash into millions of little pieces, fly

into the atmosphere, and cause destruction on the earth (Bates 11-14). This clay

is a marker between the Cretaceous and the Tertiary periods. It is now called

the K-T boundary. When the K-T boundary was looked for in New Zealand and in

Denmark, it was still found. There is another place the iridium could have come

from, and that is the center of the earth. But, unless volcanoes erupted all

over the entire world at once, this is a very unlikely place for it to have come

from. So, with all this in mind, the answer became very clear for Luis and

Walter Alvarez and their colleagues. This clay layer came from outer space (Krishtalka

20-21). Finally, in the early 1990’s, researchers found something very exciting.

They had discovered Chicxulub. Chicxulub is a non-volcanic crater buried in the

Gulf of Mexico. This crater is more than a hundred miles across. The size,

structure, and composition of this crater led scientists to believe that

approximately 65 million years ago an asteroid, two miles in diameter, came

flying towards the earth (Horner 208). As scientists look at the K-T boundary,

they noticed something else strange, nowhere on earth can dinosaur remains be

found on or above this line of clay. In fact, the closest any remains have been

found were about nine feet below it. It would be hard for scientists to say

exactly how many years nine feet of earth represents, but it’s safe to say it

would be around 100,000 years. Experts who feel an asteroid killed the dinosaurs

say that it just took all of 100,000 years for the dust cloud to resettle to the

ground, and by that time, the dinosaurs were long gone (Horner 211-212). Another

cause, less common, yet still possible, for the extinction of the dinosaurs, is

the ?Deccan Trap? thoery. The Deccan Traps was a massive volcanic eruption

that took place just about the time the dinosaurs died. So much lava was spewed

in this eruption that the Himalayan Mountains were formed. Also, though, enough

ash could have been thrown up into the atmosphere in this eruption, that the sun

would have been blocked out, killing the dinosaurs, some plants and other

animals (Psihoyos 255). Researchers are beginning to agree that a catastrophic

event at the end of the Cretaceous caused mass mortality, but not immediate

extinction. This is ironic, however, because for years scientists have tried to

prove this catastrophe caused sudden and rapid extinction. Now that rapid

extinction has been accepted, it turns out it wasn’t so rapid after all (Hs?

221). This is exactly what the gradualists believe, that this extinction was

slow. They believe this extinction was brought on by something like climate

changes, smaller volcanic eruptions, rampant spreading of deserts, or the

drainage of inland seas. All of these, however are caused by continental drift.

This is a weak belief, though, because as paleontologist Jim Jensen said,

"Continental drift can be used to explain everything- from lousy weather to

Republicans (Psihoyos 255)." If the dinosaurs died slowly, it would be very

likely that the cause would be more random than a single catastrophic event.

Some members of some groups may be eliminated, but not all members of any one

group. Looking at certain studies, this is what scientists found, a steady

decline in genera of dinosaurs from the oldest (deepest) layers of the column,

to the youngest (Horner 213-214). A column of sediments in North Dakota, "A

detailed breakdown shows that the apparently fixed number of species owes much

to rapid recovery after mass extinctions? Species diversity was drastically

reduced at the end of each geological era, not only at the species level, but

among genera and families too (Hs? 94)." There are also a fair number of

scientists who believe in both kinds of theories. They have called the

combination of events that led up to this extinction, "The worst weekend in

the history of the world (Hs? 95)."