Baseball History Essay, Research Paper

Deeply embedded in the folklore of American sports is the story of baseball’s

supposed invention by a young West Point cadet, Abner Doubleday, in the summer

of 1839 at the village of Cooperstown, New York. Because of the numerous types

of baseball, or rather games similar to it, the origin of the game has been

disputed for decades by sports historians all over the world. In 1839, in

Cooperstown, New York, Doubleday supposedly started the great game of baseball.

Doubleday, also a famous Union general in the Civil War, was said to be the

inventor of baseball by Abner Graves, an elderly miner from New York. In

response to the question of where baseball first originated, major league owners

summoned a committee in 1907. Abner Graves stepped before the committee and gave

his testimony. In Graves’ account of "the first game," the Otsego

Academy and Cooperstown’s Green’s Select School played against one another in

1839. Committeeman Albert G. Spalding, the founder of Spalding’s Sporting Goods,

favored Graves’ declaration and convinced the other committeemen that Graves’

account was true. As a result, in 1939, the committee and the State of New York

named Cooperstown and Abner Doubleday as the birthplace and inventor of

baseball, respectively. Today, many baseball historians still doubt the

testimony of Abner Graves. Historians say the story came from the creative

memory of one very old man and was spread by a superpatriotic sporting goods

manufacturer, determined to prove that baseball was a wholly American invention.

According to Doubleday’s diary, he was not playing baseball in Cooperstown, but

attending school at West Point on that day in 1839. Also, historians have found

that nowhere in Doubleday’s diary has he ever "claimed to have had anything

to do with baseball, and may never have even seen a game." This leads many

to the conclusion that Abner Doubleday did not invent baseball, but it is still

a disputed and provocative issue. Sports historians have presented impressive

evidence showing that American baseball, far from being an independent

invention, evolved out of various ball-and-stick games that had been played in

many areas of the world since the beginnings of recorded history. But in early

America, precursors of baseball included informal games of English origin such

as paddleball, trap ball, rounders, and town ball. The latter was a popular game

in colonial New England and was played by adults and children with a bat and

ball on an open field. Printed references to "base ball" in America

date back to the eighteenth century. Among these accounts is one of Albigence

Waldo, a surgeon with Washington’s troops at Valley Forge who poetically told of

soldiers batting balls and running bases in their free time. Similarly in 1834

Robin Carver’s Book of Sports related that an American version of rounders

called "base" or "goal ball" was rivaling cricket in

popularity among Americans. Indeed, cricket played a role in the evolution of

organized baseball. From this British game came umpires and innings, and early

baseball writers like Henry Chadwick used cricket terminology such as

"batsman," "playing for the side," and "excellent

field" in describing early baseball games. Likewise, the pioneer baseball

innovator Harry Wright, a cricket professional turned baseball manager, drew

heavily on his cricket background in promoting baseball as a professional team

sport in the United States. By the 1840s various forms of baseball vied for

acceptance, including the popular Massachusetts and New York versions of the

game. The Massachusetts game utilized an irregular four-sided field of play,

with the four bases located at fixed, asymmetrical distances from each other and

the "striker’s," or batter’s position away from the home base.

"Scouts," or fielders, put men out by fielding a batted ball on the

fly or on the first bounce, or by hitting a runner with a thrown ball. But this

lively version of the game was overshadowed in the late 1840s by the "New

York game," a popular version of which was devised by the members of the

New York Knickerbocker Club. Organized in 1845 by a band of aspiring gentlemen

and baseball enthusiasts, the Knickerbocker version was devised by one of their

members, Alexander J. Cartwright. Cartwright prescribed a diamond-shaped infield

with bases at ninety feet apart, a standard which has stood the test of time.

The pitching distance was set at forty-five feet from the home base, and a

pitcher was required to "pitch" a ball in a stiff-armed, underhanded

fashion. The three-strikes-are-out rule was adopted, and a batter could also be

put out by a fielder catching a batted ball in the air, or on the first bounce,

or by throwing a fielded ball to the first baseman before the runner arrived.

Other innovations included the nine-man team and three outs ending a team’s

batting in their half of an inning. Thus Cartwright’s version of baseball became

the basis of the game as presently played. Over the years, other innovations

were added, including the nine-inning standard for games, changes in the

pitching distance, and so on. On June 19, 1846, in Hoboken, New Jersey, the

first organized baseball game was played by the New York Nine and the New York

Knickerbockers. The Knickerbockers were defeated by the Nine by a score of

twenty-three to one. Mostly a Northern and Midwestern phenomenon, baseball fever

ran highest in the New York City area, where in the 1850s, games were being

played "on every available green plot within a ten-mile circuit of the

city." Spearheading the baseball boom were formally organized clubs with

officers, clubhouses and playing grounds. Among the many clubs, the

Knickerbockers sought to rule the game by posing as arbiters of play, rules, and

decorum. Since no leagues or playing schedules existed, formal games in the

1850s were arranged by correspondence between club secretaries. By the end of

the 1850s, victories and the prospect of gate receipts were becoming more

important factors. As more clubs embraced these goals, greater emphasis was

placed on obtaining good players at whatever affronts to amateur standards. The

popularity of amateur baseball clubs that played between 1845 – 1865, led to the

introduction of the first professional baseball club, the Cincinnati Red

Stockings. They are called the first professional baseball team because they

were the first team to pay their players. In 1869, they traveled the country

playing baseball and had a total payroll of less than 9,400 dollars. While

traveling across the country, the Red Stockings made a phenomenal feat, earning

eighty-four consecutive wins. This record is still held today. In the year of

their streak, the Cincinnati Red Stockings hit with an average of over .400, and

produced baseball’s first left-handed pitcher, Bobby Mitchell. The Red

Stockings’ success against the amateur teams provided incentive to create

America’s first professional baseball league, the National Association of

Baseball Players in 1858. It was formed by representatives of twenty-five clubs

for the purpose of codifying rules and establishing guidelines for organized

clubs and team competition. The Association quickly established itself as the

new arbiter of the game. Among its early rulings were the establishment of a

pitcher’s box and the standardization of the nine-inning game. The Association

also approved the practice of charging paid admissions at games and that year

saw 1,500 spectators pay 50 cents each to watch a game played between Brooklyn

and New York "all-star" teams. Although the Association established no

league or formal playing schedules, its authority was accepted and it lasted

until 1871, when it was replaced by a lame organization called the National

Association of Amateur Base Ball Players. American baseball’s popularity was at

high tide when the Civil War broke out, and the South was excluded from major

league baseball competition for many years. And yet the war also popularized the

game in all sections of the country, as soldiers in both armies played the game

in camps and in prison compounds. William Ambrose Hubert (president of the

Chicago club) and Al Spalding (a pitcher from Boston) believed that reforms were

needed to protect baseball from the corruption and instability that surrounded

the National Association. At a meeting in Louisville in 1876, Hubert, Spalding,

and representatives of the St. Louis, Cincinnati, and Louisville baseball clubs

designed a set of guidelines for the new league, named The National League of

Professional Baseball Clubs. The National League contained 8 character clubs,

however, between 1876 and 1900, only Chicago and Boston fielded a team each

year. During the first two decades of existence, The National League withstood

threats of competition from newer professional leagues. In the 1890’s, The

National League’s dominance weakened after growing to 12 teams, an unmanageable

number for that period. Although Baseball remained the countries favorite sport,

it was gaining a reputation for rowdiness and dirty play that didn’t match the

era. This prompted Byron Banford "Ban" Johnson and Charles Albert

Comiskey to found a league based on strong leadership and good virtue. In the

American League, games were not played on Sundays and women were encouraged to

attend ball games. Johnson and Comiskey set a goal to establish a new image for

the game. Recognizing that its power had declined partially by managing too many

teams, The National League sold four teams to the new league in 1900. Following

this transaction, National League officials still scoffed at this new league

when it began play in 1901. However after luring many premiere National League

Players with higher salaries and running a "kinder, gentler league,"

American League attendance exceeded National League attendance by 600,000 fans

in 1902. Early in 1903, the National League granted the American League status

as a Major League. With this, came a consistent scheduling system, player

contract regulations, and playing guidelines that the two leagues would share.

Another product of this agreement was the World Series, which pitted the

American league champion against the National League champion in a nine game

series (later shortened to seven) that would determine the World Champion of

Baseball. In 1903, 16 franchises competed for the first World Series

Championship. Though some of these teams have moved to new locations or changed

their names, the modern era of baseball began in 1903.