Boys And Girls Comparative Ess Essay, Research Paper

The movie remake of Alice Munro s short story Boys and Girls fails to represent the author s intention; in comparison to the short story. The movie eliminates crucial events, which enables the audience to have impression of what the girl is feeling and show sympathy for her. As a result of eliminating the scene in which the horse is getting killed; the audience is unaware of how the girl copes and is affected by the situation. It was stated in the story that for the girl to be able to go to sleep; she would imagine herself as a different person, a heroine. These stories were deleted in the movie therefore we are unaware of what she think and hopes for. There is also a big contrast in relationships in both versions. In the movie the girl s mother continuously supports and defends her against her grandmother s constant bickering; where as in the story all of the girl s resentment was directed towards her mother. The relationship between the girl and her father was also falsely represented in the movie. He seemed overly excited when Laird assisted in the recapturing the horse; therefore she showed resentment towards her brother and especially her father. The ending of the movie version is extremely different from the original story and shies away from author s intentions. In the closing scene of the movie; the girl is sitting in a truck and says, They ll never catch me. This is in reference to how the caught Flora and killed The movie does not give the audience very closure because it can be interpreted in very many different ways; where as in the story the ending is very abrupt and concise. There are many different interpretations taken by both versions of the story boys and girls. Unfortunately the movie seems to shy away from the author s original objective.