Winter Dreams Essay, Research Paper

Final Paper

Question #1

A.

In the opening of the story, James Joyce carefully described the protagonist?s neighborhood and surroundings in two paragraphs. As he used real names like North Richmond Street and Christian brothers School, thus by reading the first paragraph, readers are able to figure out a map of the community in which the protagonist lived. Then he went on to lead us to the late priests drawing room. The detailed description of the room appealed to our senses. Following the footsteps of the protagonist, the readers can smell the musty air of the room, see the littered kitchen, touch the curl and damp books found in the kitchen. This realistic description enables the reader to identify with the characters of the story.

The first two paragraphs establish a gray still atmosphere, which was common to Dublin?s neighborhoods these days. The boy is presented to us as a curios boy that discovers one detail after the other in his new house (the rusted bicycle pump, the books…); He is looking for something in his life. The fact he liked one book over the other because his pages were yellow imply to us he is not mature enough yet to see things under the surface but only interested of the things above.

The street he lives in is a blind street. This also implies of the protagonist?s blindness that is being enlightened at the end of the story and suddenly sees things differently.

B.

The Lottery By Shirley Jackson-

The first few lines in The Lottery, establish a very different atmosphere then the one established in ?Araby?. In the first paragraph Jackson describes the ?clear and sunny? June morning with the ?fresh warmth of a full-summer day?. The mood is very optimistic as we can see and everything seems to be just perfect (in opposite of the truth reviled in front of us at the end). In the first paragraph we can feel through Jackson?s writing the warm sunrays touching us. We can smell the flowers that are ?blossoming profusely? and can paint the ?richly green grass? in our minds.

The people appear in the first paragraph as ?villagers gathering in the square? for a fun purpose as the lottery. In first reading, we have a very strong feeling of happiness in the air. It is only at second reading that we start asking our selves questions about the first paragraph; such as why are the children picking stones and why does the lottery takes two hours and even a few days in other towns.

In opposite to ?Araby? which has a dark night atmosphere throughout the whole story and ends with the enlightened of the boy, the story begins with light and ends with depth/darkness.

Question #2

I chose to compare the boy in ?Araby? to the boy (and later man) of F.Scott Fitzgerald?s ?Winter Dreams?.